Filing a no-fault claim in New York is a paperwork race against the clock. Miss the 30-day notice deadline and the carrier can deny the entire claim before it's even reviewed. Here's the exact sequence to follow.
1. Identify the right insurance carrier
The claim goes to the insurer of the vehicle you were occupying at the time of the accident — not necessarily your own carrier. If you were a pedestrian struck by a car, the striking vehicle's insurer pays. If the at-fault vehicle is uninsured or unknown (hit-and-run), file with the Motor Vehicle Accident Indemnification Corporation (MVAIC).
2. File Form NF-2 within 30 days
Form NF-2 (Application for No-Fault Benefits) is the foundational document. It must reach the carrier within 30 days of the accident. Late filing requires a written explanation that meets the carrier's 'reasonable justification' standard — and carriers reject most of these reasons.
Send it by certified mail or fax with confirmation. Keep proof of delivery; you'll need it if the carrier later claims it never arrived.
3. Get medical treatment immediately
Gaps in treatment are a top reason carriers deny ongoing benefits. Start treatment as soon as possible after the accident and document every visit. Each medical provider should be told to bill the no-fault carrier directly using Form NF-3, within 45 days of each treatment date.
4. If you've lost wages, file the wage verification
Form NF-6 (Employer's Wage Verification Report) confirms your earnings before the accident. Get it filled out and submitted along with proof you're out of work — typically a doctor's disability note. You'll receive 80% of lost wages, up to $2,000/month for up to 3 years.
5. Comply with every verification request
When the carrier asks for additional information (a 'verification request'), respond within the deadline — usually 120 days from the first request. Non-response gives the carrier a clean denial reason. If they request an IME, attend it. Two missed IMEs in a row will end the claim.
6. If the claim is denied: arbitration
You'll receive a denial on Form NF-10 with the specific reason. From there, the dispute goes to AAA no-fault arbitration (filed through Forthright) or to court. Arbitration is faster, cheaper, and where the vast majority of NY no-fault disputes are actually decided.
Winning at arbitration depends on file quality — complete records, rebuttals of any IME or peer review, proof of timely notice and verification compliance. Most claimants benefit from professional case-prep support at this stage.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I file a no-fault claim in New York?
Submit Form NF-2 to the insurer of the vehicle you were occupying within 30 days of the accident, then have your medical providers bill the carrier directly using Form NF-3 within 45 days of each treatment.
What happens if I miss the 30-day no-fault deadline?
The carrier can deny the entire claim on timeliness grounds. You can still try with a written explanation showing reasonable justification for the delay, but acceptance is far from guaranteed.
Do I need a lawyer to file a no-fault claim?
Not to file the initial NF-2 — but if the carrier denies treatment or sends you to an IME, professional help dramatically improves your odds at arbitration.
Need expert help on your case?
If your claim has been denied or you're heading to AAA arbitration, we prepare winning files for NYC law firms, providers, and claimants. Reach out.
Request Consultation